View Single Post
Old 06-07-2005, 14:32   #5
el cid
level 3
 
Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 172
Downloads: 0
Uploads: 0
Rep Power: 0el cid is an unknown quantity at this point
Re: Indicators are overhyped... The truth about them...

Quote:
Originally Posted by TraderABC
What are indicators? ...

Fact: Indicators (such as RSI, roc, ma's, candles) NEVER predict, at best they show a CERTAIN aspect of price's action.

Fact: Many indicators are almost identical, and since they ALL look at the same data you could make a case that they all are virtually identical.

Fact: In order for a market to remain a market there MUST be a seller for each buyer. There must be a person that will be willing to take an opposite side of the trade. If everyone knows that "Oh the indicator XXX says that stock is over bought/sold so I only short/long it" then that pattern will not work out.

Decades ago people used to make a KILLING using moving averages. Try that today... I automaticly backtested DOZENS of moving average combination of 3+ years of data (the max my charting software allows for short term candles) and they all bombed if spread is taken into account.

...

Agreed.Most indicators need to fail 20 % of the time to help a trader get into the 95% club of losers.

In trending markets most of these overbought/oversold/rsi/stochs indicators etc don't work or start to fail.


Markets become irrational and rationale/logic of indicators becomes useless.When the euro rose to 1.36 , a load of overbought indications were being thwarted at 1.28 and many traders did not join the trend at 1.28

El
el cid is offline   Reply With Quote